STATE AND LOCAL POLITICS FALL 1998 (POL 231) |
LIVINGSTONE COLLEGE SALISBURY, NC 28144 |
INSTRUCTOR: | Prof. Robert Williams | CLASS ROOM: | Tubman Bldg., Rm. 208 |
CLASS TIMES: | M/W/F: 3 - 3:50 pm |
OFFICE: | Tubman Bldg., Rm. 202 | TELEPHONE: | (704) 638-5614 |
OFFICE HOURS: | Mon.,Fri.: 10 - 12 noon | E-MAIL: | drrobtwms@hotmail.com |
4net | Mon.-Fri.: 4 - 5 pm |
WEB SITES
Prof. Williams' home page Livingstone College |
|
|
There are no prerequisites for this course. |
COURSE PREREQUISITES
|
|||||
Politics in States and Communities, written by Thomas Dye, will provide the knowledge base for this course. Several copies of various editions will be on reserve at Livingstone College’s Carnegie Library. On-line material, as indicated throughout this course outline, is available by clicking on the appropriately highlighted hyperlinks. |
TEXT AND MATERIALS
|
||||||
The study of state and local politics helps us to understand the maxim that all politics involves a local dimension: all political issues—even those of national and international import—have their roots in specific places, and all political issues have (or could have) a local impact. This course focuses on federal/ The scope of the course will entail comparisons and contrasts among states and communities across America, with a particular emphasis on the issue of environmental justice. Included in our discussions will be the politics and government of the state of North Carolina, as well as of Rowan County and the city of Salisbury. |
COURSE DESCRIPTION
|
||||||
There will be two scheduled quizzes/tests on the material from the textbook. But students should not foreclose the possibility of unannounced quizzes. Any of the quizzes/tests might be in a "take-home" format. In addition, students will be evaluated on the basis of six (6) short reports dealing with various aspects of environmental justice (see the course outline below for the specific topics to be researched). These reports will detail the student's research efforts using on-line databases and archives, as well as Internet-accessible resources. Such reports are to be submitted in the format prescribed by the instructor. Submitting any assignment after its announced due date will negatively affect a student's grade (including, but not limited to, the dropping of a letter grade for each day that an assignment is late). Moreover, attendance and class participation in discussions will be factored into the student's final grade. The following table specifies the nature of the course requirements and the respective weight that each has for the student's final course grade.
|
COURSE REQUIREMENTS
|
In the following outline of topics and required readings, please note that some lectures may span more than one class session. Also, other interesting and pertinent topics might be raised, as appropriate, at any given lecture. The portions of the outline shaded in red indicate those sessions during which students are to take a quiz/test, or by which time they are expected to submit an assignment. |
COURSE OUTLINE
|
||||
The session days left unspecified in the outline below will be updated as the semester progresses. Students are required to check this web page regularly for updates, especially after the class has finished a particular topic. |
PLEASE BE ADVISED |
Introduction to the Course |
|
|||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
Aug. 24 | • Discussion of syllabus • The relevance of studying state and local politics |
|||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Ideological Orientations: Left, Right, Center | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
Aug. 26 |
• Leftists, conservatives, and all those in between | |||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
What Is Politics? | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
Aug. 28 |
•What is national politics? •What is subnational politics? |
Ch. 1: "Politics in States and Communities" | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Federalism | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
_______ |
•
The relationship between national and subnational governments • The positive and negative aspects of American federalism |
Ch. 3: "States, Communities, & Am. Federalism" | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
State and Local Governmental Institutions: The Executive | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
_______ |
• Governors • City council, mayors, and city managers |
Ch 7: "Governors in State Politics" Ch. 9: "Community Political Systems" |
||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
First Quiz | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
_______ | prepare, prepare, prepare |
Quiz covers Chs. 1, 3, 7, 9 | 4n | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net |
State and Local Governmental Institutions: Legislatures |
|
|||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
_______ |
• State legislators • Local legislative functions |
Ch. 6: "Legislators in State Politics" | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
State and Local Governmental Institutions: The Courts | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
_______ |
• The court systems • The political role of the courts |
Ch. 8: On the Courts |
||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Political Participation (In Formal Institutions) | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
_______ |
• The US party system: fragmented between national and subnational levels • Voting and elections • Interest groups: private and public • Citizens initiatives and referenda |
Ch. 4: "Participation in State Politics;" Ch. 5: "Party and Campaigns in the States" |
||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Political Participation at the Community Level (Institutional Politics) | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• Voting • Lobbying • Interest group activities |
Ch. 11: "Participation in Community Politics" | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Extra-Institutional Political Participation | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
_______ |
• Why do people choose this form of participation? • Types of extra-institutional actions |
Readings to be announced | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Second Quiz | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
_______ | study, study, study | Quiz covers Chs. 6, 8, 4, 5, 11 | 4net | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net |
What Is Environmental Justice ( EJ ) |
|
|||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• American environmentalism: an overview • Environmental injustice as oppression (racial, class, gender, etc.) • EJ as an issue of state and local politics |
Readings to be announced | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Researching Environmental Justice | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• What topics have been studied before? • Sources: periodicals, computer-databases, Internet-based sites • Search strategies: computer databases and web surfing |
At LC library, we will explore its varied resources. Using citation style guides. | Properly cite sources, & list all web sites visited & search words used. | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
How to Evaluate Resources, Internet or Otherwise | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• How have research problems been framed? • Critically review the research literature for strengths and weaknesses |
|||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Resources on Environmental Justice Available on the Internet | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• Case studies and analyses • Organizations (community, industry, public interest) • Government sources, all branches and levels (bills, laws, policies, etc.) • Data on EJ issues (demographic, hazardous substances, etc.) • Bibliographies • Link Sites |
Additional class session in library to find varied EJ resources. | Properly cite sources, & list all web sites visited & search words used. | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
In-Class Discussion | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ | In class discussion of the available EJ resources | 4n | Submit list of resources, including an evaluation of their research value. | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
History of the Environmental Justice Movement | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• Why and how did the EJ movement get started? • Types of issues (health, economic, stigma, quality of life, etc. ) • Types of activities used (local, regional, national, etc. activism) • The movement's Internet presence |
Search computer databases and the Internet for information. | As homework, continue your searches. Allocate sufficient time for this! | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net |
In-Class Discussion |
|
|||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Graded Assignment | |
______ | In-class discussion of the information discovered on the history of the EJ movement. | 4n | Submit 2-page summary in student's own words (do not extensively quote). | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Governmental Responses | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• Responses vary by state and national government institution. • Institutional dimension (executive, legislative, judicial) |
Search for bills & legislation at national & subnational levels | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
In-Class Discussion | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ | Discussion of the information unearthed on governmental responses to EJ activism. | 4n | Submit 2-page summary in student's own words (do not use extensive quotations) | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
The Role of the Courts in EJ Issues | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• The court systems as arenas of political activism • Discriminatory intent versus discriminatory outcome • The changing judicial landscape (!?) |
Readings to be announced | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Case Studies: At the Barricades | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ | • What is at stake? • Who is involved? • Examples: Chester, PA and Homer, LA • Rival interpretations of the case studies (e.g. industry responses) • Governmental responses (all levels and institutions) to particular cases |
Press ever onwards in the search using the available resources at the LC Library. | Cite cite your sources properly, and list all web sites visited and search words used. | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
In-Class Discussion | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ | Discussion of the information found on case studies of EJ activism. | 4ns | Submit 2-page summary in student's own words (do not use extensive quotations) | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net |
The Role of Social Science in the EJ Movement |
|
|||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Graded Assignment | |
______ |
• The “Scientific Method” » Its central tenets » Race/class (independent • Research designs (aggregate statistical versus case study approaches) • The aggregate statistical approach » Levels of analysis (city, county, state, region, country, etc.) » Spatial data » Strengths and weaknesses of this approach • The case study approach » Historical tools » Data available » Strengths and weaknesses of this approach |
Materials are accessible at the professor's web site. | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Methodological Issues in Social Scientific Studies | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• Operationalization » Independent variable (how to define race, class, and other variables?) » Dependent variables (how to define what is a hazard?) » Unit of analysis (how to define the geographical area that is at risk?) • Debates among social scientists, activists, and government officials: » Is environmental injustice actually widespread across the USA? • What have we learned from social science? » The incomparable research designs mean that findings cannot be generalized across the USA. » Is that lack of generalizability a satisfactory research outcome? |
|||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Analysis of a Selected US Place: An Exploratory Case Study | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ |
• Specify research design » Research question and hypothesis » Independent variable » Dependent variable • Which data sources are available for the specific place under study? |
This will be a homework assignment with an in-class discussion. | Students are to prepare and submit a research design to study a particular case of EJ activism. | |
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
Continuation of Exploratory Study | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ | • Find material and information | Use the Internet for sources. There are several web sites that provide data. | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
More Time for the Exploratory Study (If Necessary) | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
______ | • The search continues for information | The Internet has a plethora of sites, many of which allow access to EJ data. | ||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net | |
In-Class Presentation and Discussion | ||||
Session | Topics to Be Discussed | Activity | Assignment | |
_______ | Students present their findings of the exploratory studies. Discussions will ensue. |
Submit a 3- to-5 report of findings, specifying data sources, all variables used, a plausible explanation of the findings, and avenues for future research. Please indicate how a state-and- local perspective on EJ issues contributes to our understanding of the politics of this particular case study. Submit the final version of the case study during the scheduled Final Exam period. |
||
4net | 4net | 4net | 4net |
|
The following texts are useful secondary sources. Boerner, Christopher & Thomas Lambert. 1994. "Environmental Justice?" Occasional Paper # 136 (April). Center for the Study of American Business, Washington University, St. Louis. Bowen, William M., Mark J. Salling, Kingsley E. Haynes & Ellen J. Cyran. 1995. "Toward Environmental Justice: Spatial Equity in Ohio and Cleveland," Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 85:4 (December): 641-63. Briffault, Richard. 1987. "State-Local Relations and Constitutional Law," Intergovernmental Perspective, (Summer/Fall): 10-4. Brown, Phil. 1995. "Race, Class, and Environmental Health: A Review and Systematization of the Literature," Environmental Health, 69:1 (April): 15-30. Bryant, Bunyan & Paul Mohai (eds.). 1992. Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Bullard, Robert D. (ed.). 1993. Confronting Environmental Racism: Voices from the Grassroots. Boston: South End Press. Bullard, Robert D. 1994. Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class, and Environmental Quality, 2nd Ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Cheney, John L. (ed.). 1989-1990. North Carolina Manual. Raleigh, NC: Office of the Secretary of State. Collins, Ronald. 1984. "Rebirth of Reliance on State Constitutions," National Law Journal, (March 12): 25-32. Dahl, Robert. 1961. Who Governs? New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Davidson, Chandler. 1984. Minority Vote Dilution. Washington, DC: Howard University Press. Domhoff, G. William. 1983. Who Rules America Now? Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Elazar, Daniel. 1984. American Federalism: A View from the States, 3rd Ed. NY: Harper & Row. Euchner, Charles C. 1996. Extraordinary Politics: How Protest and Dissent Are Changing American Democracy. Boulder, CO: Westview. Glick, Henry & Craig Emmert. 1986. "Stability and Change: Characteristics of State Supreme Court Judges," Judicature, v. 70 (August/September): 107-12. Glickman, Theodore S. & Robert Hersh. 1995. "Evaluating Environmental Equity: The Impacts of Industrial Hazards on Selected Social Groups in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania." Discussion Paper 95-13 (March). Resources for the Future, Washington, D.C. Grady, Dennis. 1987. "State Economic Development Incentives: Why Do States Compete?" State and Local Review, (Fall): 86-94. Gray, Virginia, Herbert Jacob, & Robert Albritton (eds.). 1990. Politics in the American States, 5th Ed. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foreman. Hall, Bob. 1994. "Gold & Green: Can We Have Good Jobs and a Healthy Environment?" Durham, NC: Institute for Southern Studies (October). Hall, Bob & Mary Lee Kerr. 1991.. 1991-1992 Green Index: A State-by-State Guide to the Nation's Environmental Health. Washington, DC: Island Press. Hill, Kim Quaile. 1988. Democracies in Crisis: Public Policy Responses to the Great Depression. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Huckshorn, Robert. 1985. "Who Gave It? Who Got It? The Enforcement of Campaign Finance Laws in the States," Journal of Politics, v. 47 (August): 773-91. Jewell, Malcolm & David Olson. 1982. American State Political Parties and Elections, 2nd Ed. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole. Lawrence, David & Warren Wicker (eds.). 1982. Municipal Government in North Carolina. Institute of Government. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina. Liner, Charles (ed.). 1985. Shared Responsibility: State-Local Government Relations in North Carolina. Institute of Government. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina. Liner, Charles (ed.). 1985. State-Local Relations in North Carolina: Their Evolution and Current Status. Institute of Government. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina. Lowi, Theodore. 1967, "Machine Politics: Old and New," Public Interest, v. 9 (Fall): 86-7. Mladenka, Kenneth. 1989. "Blacks and Hispanics in Urban Politics," American Political Science Review, v. 83 (March): 165-91. Nixon, Ron. 1994. "Legislating Justice: A Report on State Environmental Justice Laws." Durham, NC: Institute for Southern Studies (August). Note. 1982. "Development of the Law—The Interpretation of State Constitutional Rights," Harvard Law Review, v. 95; pp. 1324+. Rosenthal, Donald & James Hoefler. 1989. "Competing Approaches to the Study of American Federalism and Intergovernmental Relations," Publius, 19:1 (Winter): 1-23. Shannon, John. 1987. "The Return to Fend-for-Yourself Federalism: The Reagan Mark," Intergovernmental Perspective, (Summer/Fall): 34-7. Stumpf, Harry & John Culver. 1992. The Politics of State Courts. NY: Longman. Szasz. Andrew. 1994. EcoPopulism: Toxic Waste and the Movement for Environmental Justice. Social Movements, Protest, and Contention, Volume 1. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota. Westra, Laura & Peter S. Wenz (eds.). 1995. Faces of Environmental Racism: Confronting Issues of Global Justice. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. |
COURSE BIBLIOGRAPHY
|